If there’s one thing to be said about Francis Lawrence, it’s that he knows how to please a crowd, and The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is no exception. It seems strange to call a film that is so unapologetically bleak a crowd-pleaser, but that’s Lawrence’s specialty. His previous film, The Long Walk (2025), acquired a passionate fanbase despite its cheerless subject matter. He excels at making dark material palatable enough to attract a wide audience. 

Sunrise on the Reaping is Lawrence’s fifth Hunger Games film, a prequel following fan-favorite character Haymitch Abernathy (now played by Joseph Zada) through his victory in the 50th Hunger Games, also known as the Second Quarter Quell. For these special Games, there are twice the number of tributes; Haymitch is up against 47 other children. 

Those familiar with the series have long been aware of the tragic nature of Haymitch’s backstory, and Suzanne Collins certainly does not shy away from that tragedy in the “Sunrise on the Reaping” novel. To its credit, neither does the film, and it’s at its best when it embraces the somber tone and uncomfortable timeliness of its source material. 

The film suffers from an awkward pacing, likely caused by its desire to check the boxes of scenes from the book as well as nostalgic nods to the original series. Some of these nods are harmless and sure to please the fans, like Elle Fanning’s Effie Trinket making an offhanded comment about mahogany, or composer James Newton Howard’s use of familiar music cues to reintroduce characters such as Kelvin Harrison Jr.’s Beetee. But some of the less subtle references are clunky and disrupt the more serious themes of the film. 

Sunrise is divided into three parts, the same as the book and as the previous film, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Part one rushes through its material, which makes it hard to latch onto the characters, especially for viewers who didn’t read the book and lack an already formed attachment. Characters like Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang), Louella McCoy (Molly McCann), and Lou Lou (Iona Bell) are given little time to display their complexities before the audience has to say goodbye to them. It diminishes the emotional impact of certain scenes. 

In part two, the film hits its stride. The production design team did not hold back in the design of the arena, and it’s a true visual feast. The vibrant mix of colors and uncannily lush landscape pop off the screen. The action of the Games is right back in Lawrence’s wheelhouse, and he ramps up the tension accordingly. It’s brutal, but not without its tender moments. When Haymitch finally reunites with his district partner Maysilee (Mckenna Grace), the audience gets some true tearjerker moments. 

But it’s after the Games in part three that the film truly sinks its teeth in. The tone turns from dark to downright dismal, as Haymitch’s life takes increasingly depressing turns. This is where the larger themes of propaganda, tyranny, and implicit submission are foregrounded in a devastating and poignant way. He can’t escape the powers that loom over him and everyone he loves. 

None of the above would be possible without Zada’s leading performance, which is phenomenal. He plays Haymitch’s youthful vibrancy with a natural kindness that he just can’t help. But what he really nails is the slow transformation of this boy into the man we know he becomes. As the film nears its ending, Zada slowly starts to reveal something darker blossoming underneath all of his goodness. It starts as a sadness that quickly devolves into anger, then to total desolation. It’s not at all difficult to see how this character evolves into Woody Harrelson’s portrayal.

There’s something of a magic trick to Zada’s performance, too, as there are several moments where, if you closed your eyes, you would swear it was Harrelson’s voice you heard. He nails the vocal aspect of the performance, which is part accent, part very specific impression. It’s an undertaking that, if not done right, has the potential to unsettle the whole film, and Zada completely pulls it off. He’s a star to watch. 

The supporting performances are a bit more of a mixed bag – especially those stepping into the roles of established characters. Jesse Plemons as future gamekeeper Plutarch Heavensbee is a clear standout, as the role gives him a lot of nuances to play up. Kieran Culkin’s Caesar Flickerman sometimes works and sometimes doesn’t. While it’s smart of him not to attempt to emulate Stanley Tucci’s take on the role too closely, sometimes it’s hard to believe that this could even be the same man. Ralph Fiennes is appropriately menacing as President Coriolanus Snow, but it’s nothing we haven’t seen from him before. He doesn’t get as much to work with as the two prior actors to take on the role (Donald Sutherland and Tom Blyth). 

Despite some awkwardness in the screenplay and some of the supporting performances, Sunrise on the Reaping still succeeds at its larger aspirations. It maintains its entertainment value without pulling too many punches, is a love letter to longtime fans of the franchise, and operates on a scale larger than anything we’ve seen from this franchise without interrupting the character study at its center. Anyone who cares about this character will not walk away dry-eyed, and the film happily embraces the bittersweetness of knowing this will likely be the last time we ever see him onscreen. And what a sendoff it is. 

Review Courtesy of Claire May Lewis

Feature Image Credit to Lionsgate